Feb 18, 2025
The Daily Telegraph is facing significant backlash following a disturbing incident at Cairo Takeaway Cafe in Newtown. The newspaper has been accused of conducting an undercover operation aimed at exploring the experiences of Jewish individuals living in Sydney. This operation has raised questions about ethical journalism and the implications of such tactics in a multicultural society.
On a typical Tuesday afternoon, the bustling Cairo Takeaway Cafe became the backdrop for an unsettling interaction. A man wearing a Star of David cap entered the cafe and ordered a hibiscus tea. However, what followed was anything but ordinary.
The man, who appeared to be part of the alleged undercover operation, moved to the back of the cafe, donning glasses equipped with a camera. He then approached a female staff member, leading to an awkward conversation. “Am I upsetting you being here?” he asked. The staff member replied, “No, I’m just asking you what you want.” The man followed up with a statement that raised alarm bells — “because I’m Jewish.”
Shortly after the initial encounter, a senior journalist from the Daily Telegraph arrived at the cafe with a photographer. They allegedly confronted the same female server, inquiring, “Have you got a problem with the man with the white cap?” This line of questioning left the staff member bewildered. “Why would I have a problem?” she responded, clearly taken aback by the situation.
The cafe worker later expressed her feelings of intimidation. “Who comes into a restaurant and asks me a question about this gentleman who I don’t even know?” she remarked, emphasizing the discomfort of being put in such a position.
This incident was reportedly part of a planned stunt by the Daily Telegraph, dubbed an "undercover operation." A leaked planning document outlined the day’s agenda, which included instructions to meet at Holt Street and an entry titled, “Undercover Jewish man, Ophir Birenbaum, sees what it’s like being Jewish in Sydney.”
Ophir Birenbaum is a notable figure in Sydney’s Jewish community, known for advocating unity during recent antisemitic incidents. He has frequently emphasized the importance of respect among differing communities, stating, “We have to respect each other. People can disagree respectfully.”
The cafe owner, feeling threatened by the events, decided to involve law enforcement. After a thorough three-day investigation, authorities concluded that no crime had been committed. This outcome has sparked further debate about the necessity and consequences of such journalistic tactics.
In their defense, the Daily Telegraph released a statement asserting that they never intended to provoke an incident and acknowledged that their approach could have been better handled. However, many community members are left questioning the ethics behind such an operation.
This incident at Cairo Takeaway Cafe serves as a stark reminder of the ethical responsibilities that come with journalism. It raises critical questions about the boundaries of investigative reporting and the impact on communities, particularly marginalized groups. As society continues to grapple with issues of race, identity, and respect, it is imperative for media outlets to reflect on their practices and prioritize the well-being of the communities they report on.
The Daily Telegraph's actions have ignited a conversation about the role of the press in a diverse society. Moving forward, it is essential to ensure that journalistic practices do not infringe on the rights and dignity of individuals, fostering an environment of trust and respect.
